Trade Policies

How to Trade-in Magic Cards

For the best value, take the following steps when preparing a trade:

1. Remove card sleeves

2. Separate cards into 4 piles

  • A: Cards on the Superscript Buylist
  • B: All other cards at Rare or Mythic rarity. Foil basic lands. Full art basic lands. Basic lands with original card frame printed 2002 and earlier.
  • C: Art cards, advertisement, mini-games - any non-playable cards. Tokens and Substitute cards. Non-foil basic lands with current card frame, printed 2003 and later.
  • D: All remaining cards.

3. Provide our staff with your email and phone number

4. Await your email offer

Trade Pricing Policy

We currently accept Magic and Flesh and Blood  at the following rates:

  • Buylist cards: 75% TCGPlayer Market store credit or 50% in cash
  • Cards valued at $1 or higher: 60% TCGPlayer Market store credit or 30% in cash
  • Bulk rates as high as $1 store credit per 200 cards

Valid state ID required for cash trades.